Robinline blog

Thumbtack vs Meta ads: where should your lead money go?

Cost per lead, lead quality, and the variable that decides both.

All posts

Jul 1, 2026·5 min read

Two very different machines

Thumbtack sells people already searching. Meta interrupts people who were not. High intent vs bigger pond. Neither is better; they fail differently.

Thumbtack

$15 to $40 per lead. Shared with competitors. High intent.

Meta

$8 to $25 per lead. Exclusive to you. Softer intent.

Real scoreboard

Cost per booked job, not cost per lead.

Response speed decides both

On Thumbtack you race three other companies. On Meta you race attention. Same $600 spend, wildly different results with slow vs instant replies.

TaskManualRobinlineSavings
Thumbtack ~20 leadsHours-later: ~2 to 3 booked~15 sec: win the raceCost per job drops
Meta ~40 leadsNext-day: most go coldCaught mid-scrollUp to 5x more jobs

Make every paid lead land fast

Buy leads wherever the math works in your city. Just make sure something answers in about 15 seconds with a real quote and book link, nights and weekends included.

Robinline

Less admin. Your life back.

See it work, text us to get set up today, or book a quick call if you want a walkthrough first.